This comparative analysis examines the operation of judicial precedent in Malaysia and Nigeria, two countries with distinct legal systems rooted in common law traditions. Judicial precedent, a fundamental aspect of common law jurisprudence, plays a crucial role in shaping the development of law and ensuring consistency and predictability in judicial decision-making. However, the application of precedent may vary significantly between jurisdictions due to differences in legal principles, judicial structures, and cultural contexts. Through a comprehensive review of case law, statutory provisions, and scholarly literature, this study explores the similarities and differences in the operation of judicial precedent in Malaysia and Nigeria. Key areas of analysis include the hierarchy of courts, principles of stare decisis, methods of distinguishing and overruling precedent, and the role of judicial discretion. By identifying commonalities and divergences in the application of judicial precedent, this research aims to enhance understanding of the complexities of common law systems and facilitate cross-jurisdictional comparative legal studies.

Judicial precedent, Common law, Stare decisis

Byrant A. Garner (ed). Black Law Dictionary 8th edn Thompson West 2004.

Chuks Maduka. Understanding the Concept of Judicial Precednt ann the Doctrine of Stare Decisis under the Nigrerian Legal System, Nigerian law blog spot.com/2010/08/understanding.concept-of- judicial_20_h+mc. 2010.

Esein JO. Introduction to Nigerian Legal System, Ibadan Sam Bookman publications 1998.

Hamza WA, Bulan R. An Introduction into Malaysian Legal System. Malaysia, Oxford Fajar Sdn Bhd 2003.

Ibrahim A, Joned A. The Malaysian Legal System, Kualar Lumpur, Deman Bahasolan pustaka 1995.

Ikegbu EA, Duru SA, Dafo EU. Rationality of Judicial Precedent in Nigeria’s Jurispudence, American

International journal of contemporary research, 2004, 4, 5.

Ladan MT. Introduction to Jurispudence, Classica and Islamic Law, Malt House Press Ltd. 2006.

Obilade Akintunde. The Nigerian Legal System, Ibadan, Spectrum Books Ltd. 2007.

Ogbu Osita. Modern System of Justice in Nigeria, Lagos, Tona Micro Publishers, 1995.

Paton GWA. Text Book of Juripudence, Oxford, Claredon Press 1946.

Umoh PU. Precedent in Nigerian Courts, Fourth Dimension Publishing Coy. 2010.